Is Break My Fall - Breaking Benjamin Halal or Haram?
Across the schools of thought analyzed, the highest verdict for "Break My Fall - Breaking Benjamin" is Grey Area (3/5).
| School | Verdict |
|---|---|
| Sistani | Haram (1/5) |
| Khamenei | Grey Area (3/5) |
| Hanafi | Not yet analyzed — Hanafi's general music ruling |
| Maliki | Not yet analyzed — Maliki's general music ruling |
| Shafi'i | Not yet analyzed — Shafi'i's general music ruling |
| Hanbali | Not yet analyzed — Hanbali's general music ruling |
Is Break My Fall - Breaking Benjamin halal according to Sistani?
Haram (1/5). Grand Ayatollah Sistani's criterion hinges strictly on the Expert Recognition Test: whether the musical tune type is suitable for entertainment and amusement gatherings (majālis al-lahw wal-la'ib). In 'A Code of Practice For Muslims in the West' (Book 46), Sistani explicitly states that emotional effects—such as anger, relaxation, or catharsis—are legally irrelevant to permissibility.
Is Break My Fall - Breaking Benjamin halal according to Khamenei?
Grey Area (3/5). Late Ayatollah Khamenei applies a 3-component assessment: (1) whether the music is lahwī (diverting from Allah and moral virtue), (2) whether it exhibits a mutrib quality combined with lahw, and (3) whether it is suitable for gatherings of sin (Q1121, Q1123). In his advanced Dars Khārij lectures (Ghenā va Mūsīqī, Session 314, pp.
Each school’s full reasoning — the evidence cited, where the scholars differ, and how the score was reached — continues for members.
Open the full per-school analysis →
How Islamic rulings on music work · Sistani's ruling · Khamenei's ruling · How scores are calculated
Halalify Music is an educational tool, not a fatwa service.
